Skip to content
LegalWise
Decision of 28.10.2026

Supreme Court: lost rental income during the securing of an action is assessed with regard to a lease concluded afterwards

Published 4 November 2026 · Checked against the sources 4 November 2026

On 28.10.2026 the Supreme Court (Riigikohus) explained in case 2-22-11758/70 how to determine the amount of income lost during the period an action was secured [1]. Where the injured person concluded a transaction to earn income immediately before the action was secured or after the securing measure was lifted, it can be presumed that during the securing period they could have earned income „maksimaalselt lepingus kokkulepitud ulatuses“ (translation: at most to the extent agreed in the contract) [1].

What the Supreme Court held

  • The facts: the claimant demanded from the defendant the income lost during the securing period that they would have earned by letting immovable property [1]. A lease concluded after the securing measure was lifted had been submitted to the court, but the county court wrongly took the view that the lease was not relevant for determining the amount of lost income and that an expert's opinion should be relied on [1].
  • The contract shows the possible income: „olukorras, kus hageja kui kahjustatud isik on vahetult enne hagi tagamist või pärast tagamisabinõu tühistamist teinud tehingu enda soovitud viisil tulu teenimiseks, saab eeldada, et tal oleks hagi tagamise perioodil olnud võimalus teenida tulu maksimaalselt lepingus kokkulepitud ulatuses“ (translation: where the claimant as the injured person, immediately before the action was secured or after the securing measure was lifted, concluded a transaction to earn income in the way they wished, it can be presumed that during the securing period they would have had the opportunity to earn income at most to the extent agreed in the contract) [1].
  • The annual report: it does not allow the amount of lost income to be established, but the data in it make it possible to assess „milline oli hageja maksimaalne võimalik tulu perioodil, mil tulu teenimist takistavad asjaolud puudusid“ (translation: what the claimant's maximum possible income was in the period when there were no circumstances preventing the earning of income) [1].
  • The statutory concept: lost income is „kasu, mida isik oleks vastavalt asjaoludele, eelkõige tema poolt tehtud ettevalmistuste tõttu, tõenäoliselt saanud, kui kahju hüvitamise aluseks olevat asjaolu ei oleks esinenud“ (translation: the gain that the person would probably have received according to the circumstances, in particular owing to the preparations they had made, had the circumstance giving rise to compensation not occurred) () [2]. The purpose of compensation is to place the injured person in a situation as close as possible to the one they would have been in had the circumstance giving rise to the obligation to compensate not occurred () [3].

Who is affected

Persons claiming compensation for income lost during the period an action was secured, in particular income lost from letting immovable property, and the parties from whom such damage is claimed [1].

What to bear in mind

  1. If a contract to earn income, such as a lease, was concluded immediately before the action was secured or after the securing measure was lifted, submit it to the court: in the Supreme Court's view it can be presumed that during the securing period income could have been earned at most to the extent agreed in the contract [1].
  2. An annual report alone does not show the amount of lost income, but its data help to assess the maximum possible income in a period when nothing prevented earning it [1].
  3. Lost income may also consist in the loss of an opportunity to obtain a gain () [2].

This news item gives general legal information and does not replace advice on your situation. It was prepared by an automated system; its quotes, dates and references are checked against the sources listed below.

Sources

The previous and the new wording in Riigi Teataja; the wording in force also on LegalWise's law pages. The explanatory memorandum is the legislator's explanation.

  1. [1]Riigikohus 2-22-11758/70 – Hagi tagamisega tekitatud kahju. Enne hagi tagamist või pärast tagamisabinõu tühistamist tehtud tehingu mõju saamata jäänud tulu suuruse kindlaksmääramisel (28.10.2026) · Open decision ↗
  2. [2]VÕS § 128 (RT I, 20.06.2026, 18) – Võlaõigusseadus · Open provision
  3. [3]VÕS § 127 (RT I, 20.06.2026, 18) – Võlaõigusseadus · Open provision

How does this change affect you?

Describe your situation and get an answer under the law in force, with exact references.

Ask your question

Related guides