Transitional rules of the criminal procedure reform from 01.11.2026: appeals against rulings filed earlier, earlier procedural violations and the judge who held a preliminary hearing
Published 1 November 2026 · Checked against the sources 1 November 2026 · RT I, 11.07.2026, 143
From 01.11.2026 the transitional rules to the amendments of KrMS apply: they set what applies to appeals against court rulings filed before that day, to procedural violations that occurred earlier and to court hearings already under way (KrMSRS § 2⁶, § 2⁷ and § 2⁸) [1] [2] [3].
What changes
- Appeals against rulings filed earlier: when an appeal against a ruling filed before 01.11.2026 is decided, the right to file it is determined on the basis of „määruskaebuse esitamise ajal kehtinud kriminaalmenetluse seadustiku sõnastusest“ (translation: the wording of the Code of Criminal Procedure in force when the appeal was filed) (KrMSRS § 2⁶ lg 1) [1].
- Earlier procedural violations: a party to court proceedings who does not object, although they had the opportunity and knew or should have known of the procedural error, cannot object later or rely on it when appealing the court decision (KrMS § 15¹ lg 3) [4]. An appellant may rely on a violation of procedural law in the county court only if they objected to it in the county court in time or could not object for a good reason beyond their control (KrMS § 321 lg 7) [5]. These two provisions do not restrict relying on procedural violations that occurred in court proceedings before 01.11.2026 (KrMSRS § 2⁶ lg 2) [1].
- The judge who held a preliminary hearing: KrMS § 49 lg 1 p 2¹ adds a ground for recusal where the judge would hear in general procedure a criminal case in which they acted as preliminary investigation judge or made a decision in simplified proceedings [6]. A judge is not required to recuse themselves on that ground if they held a preliminary hearing in the case before 01.11.2026 (KrMSRS § 2⁷ lg 1) [2]. According to the explanatory memorandum, replacing the judge after the preliminary hearing would very likely mean that the new judge would have to re-plan the hearing of the case, causing delays; if the judge finds that they nevertheless have a reason to step down, the law does not prevent it [7].
- Composition of the circuit court: the circuit court's panel follows the wording of the KrMS provision on court composition in force when the appeal against a ruling or the appeal was set down for hearing in the circuit court applies (KrMSRS § 2⁷ lg 2) [2]. According to the explanatory memorandum, setting an appeal down for hearing also determines the panel that will decide it [7].
- Applications to declare evidence inadmissible: where a court hearing in general procedure began before 01.11.2026 and the judicial investigation has not yet ended, the court must decide the applications to declare evidence inadmissible that were filed but not yet decided on the merits no later than the first court session held in the case after that date (KrMSRS § 2⁸) [3].
Who is affected
Parties to court proceedings and courts in criminal cases in which an appeal against a ruling was filed or the court hearing began before 01.11.2026 [1] [2] [3].
What to do
- For an appeal against a ruling filed before 01.11.2026, assess the right of appeal under the wording of KrMS in force when it was filed (KrMSRS § 2⁶ lg 1) [1].
- File applications and objections concerning procedural violations with the court at the first opportunity (KrMS § 15¹ lg 2) [4]; KrMS § 15¹ lg 3 and § 321 lg 7 do not restrict relying on violations that occurred before 01.11.2026 (KrMSRS § 2⁶ lg 2) [1].
- In general proceedings under way, expect pending applications to declare evidence inadmissible to be decided no later than the first session after 01.11.2026 (KrMSRS § 2⁸) [3].
This news item gives general legal information and does not replace advice on your situation. It was prepared by an automated system; its quotes, dates and references are checked against the sources listed below.
Sources
The previous and the new wording in Riigi Teataja; the wording in force also on LegalWise's law pages. The explanatory memorandum is the legislator's explanation.
- [1]KrMSRS § 2⁶ (RT I, 11.07.2026, 143) – Kriminaalmenetluse seadustiku rakendamise seadus – redaktsioon alates 01.11.2026new wording · Open provision
- [2]KrMSRS § 2⁷ (RT I, 11.07.2026, 143) – Kriminaalmenetluse seadustiku rakendamise seadus – redaktsioon alates 01.11.2026new wording · Open provision
- [3]KrMSRS § 2⁸ (RT I, 11.07.2026, 143) – Kriminaalmenetluse seadustiku rakendamise seadus – redaktsioon alates 01.11.2026new wording · Open provision
- [4]KrMS § 15¹ (RT I, 11.07.2026, 79) – Kriminaalmenetluse seadustik – redaktsioon alates 01.11.2026new wording · Open provision
- [5]KrMS § 321 (RT I, 11.07.2026, 79) – Kriminaalmenetluse seadustik – redaktsioon alates 01.11.2026new wording · Open provision
- [6]KrMS § 49 (RT I, 11.07.2026, 79) – Kriminaalmenetluse seadustik – redaktsioon alates 01.11.2026new wording · Open provision
- [7]Seletuskiri 560 SE (15. Riigikogu) – Kriminaalmenetluse seadustiku ja teiste seaduste muutmise seadus (kohtumenetluse optimeerimine ja kohtulahendite avalikkus) — selgitus sättele KrMS § 49 · Open the bill ↗
How does this change affect you?
Describe your situation and get an answer under the law in force, with exact references.
Ask your questionRelated guides
- Challenging a fine for a misdemeanourHow you challenge a fine depends on the procedure in which it was imposed. A fine notice (warning fine, hoiatustrahv) for a traffic offence recorded by a…