Employee liability for damage caused to the employer in Estonia
Last checked against the sources 1 November 2026 · Published 1 November 2026
In short: If an employee breached the employment contract intentionally, they are liable for all the damage caused to the employer (TLS § 74 lg 1) [1]; in the case of negligence, the extent of compensation is determined taking into account, among other things, the employee's duties, the degree of fault, the working conditions, the risk of the work and the employee's pay (TLS § 74 lg 2) [1]. Regardless of fault, an employee is liable for the safekeeping of property entrusted to them under a material liability agreement, which is valid only if, among other things, it was concluded in writing and sets a monetary limit of liability (TLS § 75 lg 1 ja 2) [2]. Out of court, the employer may set off damage against wages only with the employee's consent given in a form that can be reproduced in writing (TLS § 78 lg 1) [3]. The employer's claim expires within 12 months (TLS § 74 lg 4) [1].
Is your situation different?
Describe your situation — the answer cites the law down to the subsection and is checked against the sources before it is shown.
Intent and negligence: how far is the employee liable?
The Employment Contracts Act distinguishes two situations:
- intentional breach – the employee is liable for all the damage caused to the employer as a result of the breach (TLS § 74 lg 1) [1];
- breach through negligence – the employee is liable to an extent determined taking into account their duties, the degree of fault, the instructions given to them, the working conditions, the risk arising from the nature of the work, the length of their employment with the employer and their conduct so far, their pay, and the employer's reasonably expected means of avoiding or insuring the damage (TLS § 74 lg 2) [1].
In the case of negligence, compensation is reduced by the damage resulting from the risk of typical damage associated with the employer's activity (TLS § 74 lg 2) [1].
The forms of fault are negligence, gross negligence and intent (VÕS § 104 lg 2) [4]. Negligence is failure to exercise the care required in commerce; gross negligence is failure to exercise it to a significant extent (VÕS § 104 lg 3 ja 4) [4]. According to the Riigikohus (Supreme Court), compensation for damage caused by gross negligence should be limited less than for ordinary negligence (RK 3-2-1-56-17) [5].
When claiming compensation, the employer cannot rely on § 138 of the Law of Obligations Act (TLS § 74 lg 7) [1], under which compensation may be claimed from all persons each of whom could have caused the damage (VÕS § 138 lg 1) [6].
An agreement deviating to the employee's detriment from what the Employment Contracts Act and the Law of Obligations Act provide on the parties' liability is void, unless the Employment Contracts Act allows such an agreement (TLS § 2) [7].
Material liability agreement
Under a material liability agreement, the employee assumes liability, regardless of fault, for the safekeeping of property given to them for performing their duties (TLS § 75 lg 1) [2]. The agreement is valid only if (TLS § 75 lg 2) [2]:
- it has been concluded in writing;
- it is reasonably and recognisably limited for the employee in terms of place, time and objects;
- only the employee or a specified group of employees has access to the property entrusted;
- a monetary limit of liability has been agreed;
- the employer pays the employee reasonable compensation taking into account the limit of liability.
The Riigikohus has explained that one of the main factors in assessing whether the compensation is reasonable is its relation to the limit of liability, but other factors such as the value of the property handed over and the probability of damage must also be considered (RK 3-2-1-56-17) [5]. The central purpose of the agreement should be to ease the employer's burden of proof where the employee is entrusted with money or a changing set of items (e.g. warehouse stock), not to put the risk of destruction of or damage to a valuable work tool on the employee (RK 3-2-1-56-17) [5]. A material liability agreement cannot replace insurance (RK 3-2-1-56-17) [5].
Damage to a third party
If the employee is liable for damage caused to a third party in the course of performing their duties, the employer must release the employee from the obligation to compensate the damage and bear the necessary legal costs, and must perform these obligations itself (TLS § 76 lg 1) [8]. The employer may then claim compensation from the employee under TLS § 74 (TLS § 76 lg 2) [8], i.e. under the rules on intent and negligence described above.
If the employer's liability towards the third party is excluded or limited by contract or by law, the exclusion or limitation applies to the same extent to the employee who harmed the third party in the course of the employer's business (TLS § 76 lg 3) [8]. These rules do not exclude or limit the employee's liability for damage caused to a third party intentionally (TLS § 76 lg 4) [8].
Not starting work or leaving without notice
If the employee does not start work without good reason or leaves work without notice, the employer, if it terminates the employment contract for that reason, may claim compensation for damage (TLS § 74 lg 3) [1]. The damage is presumed to equal the employee's average wage for one month (TLS § 74 lg 3) [1]. If the claim is not settled by set-off, the employer must file it within 20 working days of the employee's failure to appear or departure (TLS § 74 lg 3) [1].
The employer and the employee may agree, in a form that can be reproduced in writing, on a contractual penalty for a culpable breach of the employment contract by the employee where the employee refuses to start work or leaves work in order to end the employment relationship (TLS § 77 lg 1) [9]. The penalty does not exclude a claim for additional damage under TLS § 74 lg 3 to the extent the penalty does not cover it (TLS § 77 lg 2) [9]. Under the Law of Obligations Act, a court may, at the request of the party obliged to pay, reduce an unreasonably high contractual penalty to a reasonable amount (VÕS § 162 lg 1) [10], but a reduction cannot be requested after the penalty has been paid (VÕS § 162 lg 3) [10].
Can the employer deduct the damage from wages?
Out of court, the employer may set off its claims against the employee's claim for wages with the employee's consent given in a form that can be reproduced in writing, unless the law provides otherwise (TLS § 78 lg 1) [3]. Consent given before the right of set-off arose is void, except consent to set off an amount exceeding the agreed limit of expenses the employee incurs at the employer's expense (TLS § 78 lg 2) [3]. A general consent written into the employment contract in advance therefore does not entitle the employer to deduct damage from wages.
Without consent, the employer may withhold from wages only an advance paid to the employee that the employee must return and, when the employment contract ends, the pay for annual leave taken but not yet earned (TLS § 78 lg 3) [3].
In a set-off, the employer must take into account § 132 of the Code of Enforcement Procedure on levying execution (TLS § 78 lg 4) [3]. Under its general rule, income is not seized if it does not exceed the minimum wage laid down for one month (TMS § 132 lg 1) [11].
When does the employer's claim expire?
The employer's claim against the employee for damage arising in the performance of their duties expires within 12 months of the time the employer learned or should have learned of the damage and of the person obliged to compensate it, but no later than three years after the damage arose (TLS § 74 lg 4) [1].
Where the employer claims back from the employee compensation it paid to a third party (TLS § 76 lg 2) [8], the claim, according to the Riigikohus, expires within 12 months as a rule from the time the employer paid the compensation to the third party or, by way of exception, from when a court judgment obliging the employer to pay entered into force (RK 3-2-1-11-17) [12].
A creditor of the employer may also claim compensation for the employer if it cannot satisfy its claims from the employer's assets; if the employer is declared bankrupt, only the trustee in bankruptcy may file the claim on the employer's behalf (TLS § 74 lg 5) [1]. The creditor or trustee keeps this right even if the employer has waived the claim, reached a compromise with the employee or shortened the limitation period (TLS § 74 lg 6) [1].
What the law says
- „Kui töötaja on töölepingut tahtlikult rikkunud, vastutab ta rikkumise tagajärjel kogu tööandjale tekitatud kahju eest.“ (translation: if an employee has breached the employment contract intentionally, they are liable for all the damage caused to the employer as a result of the breach; TLS § 74 lg 1) [1]
- „Hüvitist vähendatakse tööandja tegevusega seonduva tüüpilise kahju tekkimise riski tagajärjel tekkinud kahju võrra.“ (translation: compensation is reduced by the damage resulting from the risk of typical damage associated with the employer's activity; TLS § 74 lg 2) [1]
- „Varalise vastutuse kokkuleppega võtab töötaja sõltumata süüst vastutuse temale tööülesannete täitmiseks antud vara säilimise eest.“ (translation: by a material liability agreement the employee assumes liability, regardless of fault, for the safekeeping of property given to them for performing their duties; TLS § 75 lg 1) [2] – but only if all the conditions of TLS § 75 lg 2 are met (TLS § 75 lg 2) [2].
- „Enne tasaarvestuse õiguse tekkimist antud nõusolek on tühine, välja arvatud, kui tegemist on nõusolekuga töötaja poolt tööandja arvel tehtavate kulude kokkulepitud limiiti ületava summa tasaarvestamiseks.“ (translation: consent given before the right of set-off arose is void, except consent to set off an amount exceeding the agreed limit of expenses the employee incurs at the employer's expense; TLS § 78 lg 2) [3]
What to do
- If the employer claims compensation, ask whether it relies on intent or negligence: the employee is liable for all the damage in the case of an intentional breach, and in the case of negligence to an extent determined by the factors listed in TLS § 74 lg 2 (TLS § 74 lg 1 ja 2) [1].
- If the claim is based on a material liability agreement, check whether it is in writing, whether the property is defined, whether only you or a specified group of employees had access to it, whether a limit of liability was agreed and whether you were paid reasonable compensation – if any condition is missing, the agreement is not valid (TLS § 75 lg 2) [2].
- Do not consent to the damage being deducted from your wages if you dispute the claim: a set-off against wages out of court is allowed only with your consent in a form that can be reproduced in writing, and consent given in advance is as a rule void (TLS § 78 lg 1 ja 2) [3].
- Check the limitation period: the employer's claim expires 12 months after it learned or should have learned of the damage and the person liable, and no later than three years after the damage arose (TLS § 74 lg 4) [1].
- If no agreement is reached, a dispute arising from the employment relationship can be resolved by the labour dispute committee (TvLS § 2 lg 1 p 1) [13] or in court (TvLS § 2 lg 3) [13].
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to pay the full cost of a work tool I broke by accident?
Not necessarily. In the case of negligence, the extent of compensation is determined taking into account, among other things, the degree of fault, the risk arising from the nature of the work, the employee's pay and the employer's means of avoiding or insuring the damage, and compensation is reduced by the typical risk of the employer's activity (TLS § 74 lg 2) [1]. An employee is liable for all the damage in the case of an intentional breach (TLS § 74 lg 1) [1].
Can the employer simply deduct the damage from my wages?
As a rule only with your consent given in a form that can be reproduced in writing, and consent given before the right of set-off arose is void (TLS § 78 lg 1 ja 2) [3]. Without consent, the employer may withhold only an advance that must be returned and, when the contract ends, the pay for annual leave taken but not yet earned (TLS § 78 lg 3) [3].
I signed a material liability agreement. Am I now liable for everything?
The agreement is valid only if all the conditions of TLS § 75 lg 2 are met, including a monetary limit of liability and reasonable compensation for the employee (TLS § 75 lg 2) [2]. Even under a valid agreement, you are liable regardless of fault only for the safekeeping of property given to you for performing your duties (TLS § 75 lg 1) [2].
A client is claiming damages from me, although I was working for my employer. Who pays?
If you are liable for damage caused to a third party in the course of your duties, the employer must release you from the obligation to compensate the damage and bear the necessary legal costs, and perform them itself (TLS § 76 lg 1) [8]. The employer may later claim compensation from you under the rules of TLS § 74 (TLS § 76 lg 2) [8].
What happens if I leave work without notice?
If the employer terminates the employment contract for that reason, it may claim compensation, and the damage is presumed to equal your average wage for one month (TLS § 74 lg 3) [1]. If the claim is not settled by set-off, the employer must file it within 20 working days of your departure (TLS § 74 lg 3) [1].
Is something different in your situation?
The guide describes the general rule. Ask about your situation: the answer cites the provisions down to the subsection and point and is checked against the sources before it is shown.
For lawyers: an AI legal assistant that cites the provision down to the subsection →
This guide gives general legal information and does not replace an attorney's advice on your situation. It was prepared with the help of an automated system; its quotes, figures and references were checked against the sources listed below.
Sources
The text in force on LegalWise's law pages; the official publication in Riigi Teataja.
- [1]TLS § 74 (RT I, 03.07.2026, 35) – Töölepingu seadus · Open provision
- [2]TLS § 75 (RT I, 03.07.2026, 35) – Töölepingu seadus · Open provision
- [3]TLS § 78 (RT I, 03.07.2026, 35) – Töölepingu seadus · Open provision
- [4]VÕS § 104 (RT I, 20.06.2026, 18) – Võlaõigusseadus · Open provision
- [5]Riigikohus 3-2-1-56-17 – Varalise vastutuse kokkulepe korral mõistliku hüvitise maksmine (21.06.2017) · Open decision ↗
- [6]VÕS § 138 (RT I, 20.06.2026, 18) – Võlaõigusseadus · Open provision
- [7]TLS § 2 (RT I, 03.07.2026, 35) – Töölepingu seadus · Open provision
- [8]TLS § 76 (RT I, 03.07.2026, 35) – Töölepingu seadus · Open provision
- [9]TLS § 77 (RT I, 03.07.2026, 35) – Töölepingu seadus · Open provision
- [10]VÕS § 162 (RT I, 20.06.2026, 18) – Võlaõigusseadus · Open provision
- [11]TMS § 132 (RT I, 11.07.2026, 97) – Täitemenetluse seadustik · Open provision
- [12]Riigikohus 3-2-1-11-17 – Töötaja vastu esitatud kahju hüvitamise nõude aegumine (05.04.2017) · Open decision ↗
- [13]TvLS § 2 (RT I, 24.11.2020, 6) – Töövaidluse lahendamise seadus · Open provision
Related guides
- Working time and rest periodsUnder the Employment Contracts Act (töölepingu seadus, TLS), an employee is presumed to work 40 hours in a seven-day period and 8 hours a day (TLS § 43…
- Overtime and how it is compensated in EstoniaUnder the Employment Contracts Act (töölepingu seadus, TLS), overtime (ületunnitöö) is work beyond the agreed working time, and as a rule it is done by…
- Minors working in EstoniaUnder the Employment Contracts Act (töölepingu seadus, TLS), an employer may not conclude an employment contract with a minor under 15 or a minor who is…
- Redundancy and redundancy pay in EstoniaUnder the Employment Contracts Act (töölepingu seadus, TLS), redundancy (koondamine) is the extraordinary termination of an employment contract by the…
Is your situation different?
Describe your situation and get an answer based on the law in force, with exact references.
Ask your own question